The perfect potato salad: classic recipe and 4 global twists you should try

How to make creamy potato salad — and avoid the mistakes that turn it into mush

Simple, hearty, and loved across the world — potato salad is more than just side dish. But getting it just right means choosing the right potato and mastering the balance of dressing and add-ins.

The classic version includes firm potatoes, boiled eggs, onions, and light mayo. But there are dozens of twists: spicy mustard, crunchy pickles, even vegan dressings with olive oil and herbs.

The key is texture — overcooked potatoes turn everything into paste. For best results, use waxy varieties like Yukon Gold or red potatoes.

According to a recent article, international versions reveal how much culture influences this humble dish.

🥗 Potato salad variations

Style Main ingredients Flavor Notes
Classic Potatoes, egg, mayo, onion Creamy, mild Picnic staple
German Vinegar, bacon, parsley Savory, warm Often served hot
American Pickles, mustard, mayo Sweet and tangy Yellowish dressing
Vegan Olive oil, herbs, lemon Fresh, light No dairy or eggs

📉 Myth vs truth

  • Myth: Potato salad always has mayo.
    Truth: Oil-based and dairy-free versions are common.
  • Myth: All potatoes work fine.
    Truth: Use waxy types to avoid mush.
  • Myth: It should be served warm.
    Truth: Most versions are cold, though some like German salad are warm.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

  • Can I make it ahead?
    Yes — but add dressing closer to serving for best texture.
  • How long does it last?
    3–4 days in the fridge, sealed.
  • How to make it lighter?
    Use yogurt or a vinaigrette instead of heavy mayo.

Fun fact: Germans eat warm potato salad at Christmas, Americans love it at barbecues, and Russians often mix it into Olivier salad — proving the potato salad’s global fame.

Subscribe to Pravda.Ru Telegram channel, Facebook, RSS!

Author`s name Anton Kulikov